1. A Feudal Quarrel That Outgrew Its Origins
The war's starting point was a genuine legal puzzle. When the direct Capetian line expired in the early fourteenth century, the French nobility chose Philip of Valois over Edward III partly on the grounds that the English king's claim descended through a woman. Edward accepted this initially, then revived the claim when relations soured. What began as a dispute intelligible within medieval inheritance law gradually accumulated deeper stakes: wounded prestige, ransomed kings, burned harvests, and populations that came to see the other side not as feudal rivals but as enemies. The original legal argument never disappeared, but the war long outlasted any simple resolution of it.
Why it matters: Understanding the feudal starting point prevents the mistake of reading modern nationalism backward into the conflict's origins; the transformation into something resembling national war was a consequence, not a cause.